Are These YA Characters on the Naughty or Nice List?

🎶 We’re reading a book, we’re reading it twice, we’re gonna find out who’s naughty or nice… caaause morally-obscure-YA-characters are coming to town!! 🎵🎶

This holiday season has given us the gift of Cynthia Hand’s THE AFTERLIFE OF HOLLY CHASE, the perfectly fun and festive novel to curl up with on these winter days (you can start with this excerpt right now). It’s also brought us our first Epic Reads box!

In this book, Holly Chase is just your average spoiled teenager who refuses to change her ways after being visited by the three ghosts of Christmas… and then she dies. We promise that’s not a spoiler, she dies in the first chapter. Plus, the word “afterlife” is in the book’s title, so really you should have seen that coming! Anyway, now Holly’s stuck working as a ghost at Project Scrooge and trying to convince other teens to become better people. But this year’s Scrooge is very different, so you’ll have to read the book to find out what happens!

It’s probably safe to say that Holly lived most of her life on the Naughty list, so this got us thinking—where would other loveable but morally ambiguous YA characters fall? Vote below on who you think has been Naughty, and who’s been Nice!


Are These YA Characters on the Naughty or Nice List?


Did you check your list twice? Tell us who was the hardest to place in the comments!

Up next: